Messenger Stakes: Things that make you go Hmmm

Yonkers Raceway will host both the Yonkers Trot and the Messenger Stakes on its famed half-mile track on Saturday, Sept. 2. Both are second legs of the trotting and pacing Triple Crown and both have $500,000 purses, so, in short, they are big races on the harness racing calendar.

The Trot drew 12 entrants and, thus, will have two eliminations contested this Saturday to narrow the field to eight.

The Messenger Stakes drew nine entrants, and believe it or not, will have an elimination heat on Saturday to eliminate… one horse. Does this make sense? Nine pacers will contest the elimination, but only eight can run in the final. I may not be the brightest bulb on the tree, but can’t they just run nine in a Messenger final? They could put the nine behind the one and have at it. We see this at many half-mile tracks like Monticello.

Another option would be to put the nine behind the one and make the race 1 1/8 miles. This was something we saw on Hambletonian Day when there were more than 10 horses in a race. The extra eighth of a mile serves to even things out and, in some ways, can make for better racing.

It seems to me that there are many ways to address this that wouldn’t involve a qualifying race designed to eliminate a single horse. The Messenger elimination does offer a $40,000 purse, so there is incentive to win the race and cash the winner’s check.

And winning will guarantee a good spot in the final (the last thing any driver/trainer/owner wants at Yonkers is to start from gate eight). Even though the moved-back finish line has helped the outside horses, it hasn’t helped them that much.

If you want evidence, look no further than the talented Somewhere in LA, who is a regular in the Saturday open pace. When he starts from positions one thru five, he usually finds his way to the winner’s circle; when he starts from the eight-spot, he is tough to find during the race. It is no longer impossible, but it remains improbable to win from there at Yonkers.

Another option would be to eliminate the elimination and simply take the top eight moneymakers in 2017. The Gerrity Memorial at Saratoga did just that. If the horse ranked ninth or worse in earnings, it didn’t make the field. Dr. J Hanover blazed a 1:46.4 at Mohawk, but because he didn’t have enough in the bank, he was relegated to an undercard race on Gerrity night.

The Spirit of Massachusetts Trot did the same thing for its inaugural running. There were 37 nominated and, on July 28, the top nine earners competed in a race that was won by JL Cruze in track-record time.

If I were the racing czar, I would make the Messenger Stakes 1 1/8 miles and allow nine to go to post.